My MicroSDXC Card Appears to be Incompatible with the Samsung Note 4

I bought a used Note 4 to replace my aging Galaxy S4. I have a 128GB PNY MicroSDXC I used with my S4 and I had no issues. My mother has a Note 4 as well, but it was purchased brand new. Both my used Note 4 and my mother's Note 4 does not recognize the 128GB PNY MicroSDXC card, but my computer and my old S4 recognizes the PNY card perfectly fine.

Is there something incompatible about the PNY microSD cards? I searched online and I cannot find anything on this issue.

This problem is a beyond me because I thought SD cards were universal.